h1

Ideas on Gardening

December 6, 2007

So, here’s a question from the perspective of a missional, simple-church, organic community pastor in Michigan.

The more I hear about this buzz word “community” the more I get concerned if we are reaching for something intangible. In his book, “The Forgotten Ways” Alan Hirsch makes a good point when talking about the difference between “community” and “communitas.” Hirsch basically argues that if we are merely  seeking to create a group of people (no matter the size) that have affinity, are connected to God and one another and come together for worship, then we are missing the point of being the Church. Without a missional focal point, we won’t achieve “communitas.”

I like the image statement that a friend gave me a few years ago which compares our work to an organic gardener. He would say that our role is not the “creator” of community, but rather the one that helps keep the soil rich and able to produce community within it. We must re-learn that God is the only being capable of drawing, and connecting people, and we as pastors are merely to act with God’s movement, and tend to the garden so that it may grow fertile and vibrant.

So I ask, is community something we really should be striving for? Is it really something we can plan for? Or, should we learn to step back, listen for God’s movement around us and work to create organic spaces for community to blossom?

2 comments

  1. I’ve heard about community vs. comminutas before, but still looking for a clear description and distinction. Can you help me out there? (Obviously, I haven’t read Hirsh yet.) In particular, how are they different re. “…the point of being the Church. Without a missional focal point,we won’t achieve “communitas.”

    Maybe you can just unpack “missional focal point.”

    Thanks –

    Tim


  2. Tim, while I don’t have a copy of The Forgotten Ways in front of me to give you a Hirsch definition…my memory says the difference has to do with the role mission or “a shared objective” plays in a group. Communitas is what happens between people when they share a common ordeal or missional goal. Community is that bonding we talk about that often is used to refer to a group of familiar friends. That’s nice but not gritty enough for Hirsch. Again, read HIrsch for a more complete commentary on the differences. b



Leave a Comment